Reliability of independent kinetic variables and measures of inter-limb asymmetry associated with bilateral drop-landing performance
- within-session reliability,
- kinetic variables,
- inter-limb asymmetry
The purpose of this investigation was to establish the within-session reliability for peak vertical ground reaction force (vGRF), time to peak vGRF, and loading rate, both unilaterally and bilaterally, during a drop-landing task as well as the reliability of inter-limb asymmetry in peak vGRF. Twenty-two men (age = 22 ± 4 years; height = 180.4 ± 6.1 cm; mass = 77.9 ± 14.0 kg) and 17 women (age = 20.4 ± 3.6 years; height = 164.6 ± 9.4 cm; mass = 60.3 ± 9.8 kg) volunteered for a single testing session. Participants completed three maximum countermovement jumps (CMJ) to establish maximum jump height before performing five bilateral drop-landings from 50%, 100%, and 150% of their maximum CMJ height. The bilateral drop-landing protocol was then repeated after a 10 min recovery. Systematic bias, intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), coefficient of variation (CV%) and minimal detectable change (MDC) values for each kinetic measurement was calculated for the left and right leg, as well as their average. There was no systematic bias present between trials (P > 0.05). All kinetic measurements showed relative reliability, ranging from large to near perfect (ICC = 0.57–0.95). Absolute reliability ranged considerably depending on the measure and drop-height, with peak vGRF and time to peak GRF showing the greatest reliability at higher drop heights (CV% = 6.6–9.7%). Loading rate for all drop heights demonstrated CV% ranging 13.0–27.6%. Furthermore, MDC values for inter-limb asymmetries in peak vGRF ranged between 14.5–16.2% for all drop heights. Overall, many of the kinetic measurements evaluated were sufficiently reliable to detect typical changes in bilateral drop-landing performance when greater drop heights were used.
- J.S. Dufek and B.T. Bates, Biomechanical factors associated with injury during landing in jump sports, Sports Medicine, 12 (1991) 326-337.
- J. Yanci, and J. Camara, Bilateral and unilateral vertical ground reaction forces and leg asymmetries in soccer players, Biology of Sport, 33 (2016) 179-183.
- G.H. Wadley and J.P. Albright, Women’s intercollegiate gymnastics: injury patterns and ‘‘permanent’’ medical disability, American Journal of Sports Medicine, 21 (1993) 314–320.
- N.A. Bates, K.R. Ford, G.D. Myer and T.E. Hewett, Impact differences in ground reaction force and center of mass between the first and second landing phases of a drop vertical jump and their implications for injury risk assessment, Journal of Biomechanics, 46 (2013) 1237-1241.
- D.R. Ortega, E.C.R. Bíes, and F.J.B.de la Rosa Analysis of the vertical ground reaction forces and temporal factors in the landing phase of a countermovement jump, Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 9 (2010) 282-287.
- C.H. Yeow, P.V.S. Lee, and J.C.H. Goh, Non-linear flexion relationships of the knee with the hip and ankle, and their relative postures during landing, Knee, 18 (2011) 323-328.
- C.M. Fong, J.T. Blackburn, M.F. Nocross, M. McGrath, and D.A. Padua, Ankle-dorsiflexion range of motion and landing biomechanics, Journal of Athletic Training, 46 (2011) 5-10.
- T.E. Hewett, G.D. Myer, K.R. Ford, R.S. Heidt Jr, A.J. Colosimo, S.G. McLean, A.J. Van den Bogert, M.V. Paterno and P. Succop, Biomechanical measures of neuromuscular control and valgus loading of the knee predict anterior cruciate ligament injury risk in female athletes: a prospective study, The American Journal of Sports Medicine, 33 (2005) 492-501.
- M.F. Norcross, J.T. Blackburn, B.M. Goerger and DA. Padua, The association between lower extremity energy absorption and biomechanical factors related to anterior cruciate ligament injury, Clinical Biomechanics, 25 (2010) 1031-1036.
- R.W. Bisseling, A.L. Hof, S.W. Bredeweg, J. Zwerver and T. Mulder, Are the take-off and landing phase dynamics of the volleyball spike jump related to patellar tendinopathy?, British Journal of Sports Medicine, 42 (2008) 483-489.
- S.P. Bird and W.J. Markwick, Musculoskeletal screening and functional testing: considerations for basketball athletes, International Journal of Sports Physical Therapy, 11 (2016) 784–802.
- M.A.D. Britto, P.S. Franco, E. Pappas, and F.P. Carpes, Kinetic asymmetries between forward and drop jump landing tasks, The Revista Brasileira de Cineantropometria e Desempenho Humano, 17 (2015) 661-671.
- M.K. Rowley and J.G. Richards, Increasing plantar flexion angle during landing reduces vertical ground reaction forces, loading rates and the hip’s contribution to support moment within participants, Journal of Sports Sciences, 33 (2015) 1922-1931.
- P.K. Schot, B.T. Bates and J.S. Dufek, Bilateral performance symmetry during drop landing: a kinetic analysis, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 26 (1994) 1153-1159.
- E.L. Radin, K.H. Yang, C. Riegger, V.L. Kish and J.J. O'Connor, Relationship between lower limb dynamics and knee joint pain, Journal of Orthopaedic Research, 9 (1991) 398-405.
- G. Atkinson and A.M. Nevill, Statistical methods for assessing measurement error (reliability) in variables relevant to sports medicine, Sports Medicine, 26 (1998) 217-238.
- S. Cormack, R. Newton, M. McGuigan and T. Doyle, Reliability of measures obtained during single and repeated countermovement jumps, International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance, 3 (2008) 131-144.
- N. Hori, R.U. Newton, N. Kawamori, M.R. McGuigan, W.J. Kraemer and K. Nosaka, Reliability of performance measurements derived from ground reaction force data during countermovement jump and the influence of sampling frequency, The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 23 (2009) 874-882.
- G. Markovic, D. Dizdar, I. Jukic and M. Cardinale, Reliability and factorial validity of squat and countermovement jump tests, The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research,18 (2004) 551-555.
- F. Slinde, C. Suber, L.Suber, C.E. Edwén and U. Svantesson, Test-retest reliability of three different countermovement jumping tests, The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 22 (2008) 640-644.
- C.R. James, J.A. Herman, J.S. Dufek and B.T. Bates, Number of trials necessary to achieve performance stability of selected ground reaction force variables during landing. Journal of Sports Science and Medicine, 6 (2007) 126-134.
- T.C. Mauntel, R.L. Begalle, T.R. Cram, B.S. Frank, C.J. Hirth, T. Blackburn and D.A. Padua, The effects of lower extremity muscle activation and passive range of motion on single-leg squat performance, The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 27 (2013) 1813–1823.
- N. Benjanuvatra, B.S. Lay, J.A.Alderson and B.A. Blanksby, Comparison of ground reaction force asymmetry in one-and two-legged countermovement jumps, The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 27 (2013) 2700-2707.
- G.L. Moir, Three different methods of calculating vertical jump height from force platform data in men and women, Measurement in Physical Education and Exercise Science, 12 (2008) 207-218.
- C.R. James, B.T. Bates and J.S. Dufek, Classification and comparison of biomechanical response strategies for accommodating landing impact, Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 19 (2003) 106-118.
- C.E. Milner, J.T. Fairbrother, A. Srivatsan and S. Zhang, Simple verbal instruction improves knee biomechanics during landing in female athletes, Knee, 19 (2012) 399-403.
- B.D. Roewer, K.R. Ford, G.D. Myer, and T.E. Hewett, The ‘impact’ of force filtering cut-off frequency on the peak knee abduction moment during landing: artefact or ‘artifiction’?, British Journal of Sports Medicine, 48 (2014) 464–468.
- M.C. Hoch, K.E. Farwell, S.L. Gaven and J.T. Weinhandl, Weight-bearing dorsiflexion range of motion and landing biomechanics in individuals with chronic ankle instability. Journal of Athletic Training, 50 (2015) 833-839.
- M.V. Paterno, K.R. Ford, G.D. Myer, R. Heyl and T.E. Hewett, Limb asymmetries in landing and jumping 2 years following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine, 17 (2007) 258-262.
- M.J. Jordan, P. Aagaard and W. Herzog, Lower limb asymmetry in mechanical muscle function: a comparison between ski racers with and without ACL reconstruction, Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports, 25 (2015) 301-309.
- Field, A. Discovering statistics using IBM SPSS statistics. London: SAGE Publications Ltd, 2013.
- Hopkins W. A Scale of Magnitudes for Effect Statistics [Internet] http://www.sportsci.org/resource/stats/index.html. A New View of Statistics. Internet Society for Sport Science, 2002.
- B.L. Riemann and M.R. Lininger, Statistical primer for athletic trainers: the essentials of understanding measures of reliability and minimal important change, Journal of Athletic Training, 53 (2018) 98-103.
- Hopkins W. Spreadsheets for Analysis of Validity and Reliability (Excel spreadsheet) [Internet] http://www.sportsci.org/resource/stats/index.html. Internet Society for Sports Science, 2015.
- M.S. Walsh, K.R. Ford, K.J. Bangen, G.D. Myer and T.E. Hewett, The validation of a portable force plate for measuring force-time data during jumping and landing tasks, The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 20 (2006) 730-734.
- M. Stokes, Reliability and repeatability of methods for measuring muscle in physiotherapy, Physiotherapy: Theory and Practice, 1 (1985) 71-6.
- V. Vu, A. Walker, N. Ball and W. Spratford, Ankle restrictive firefighting boots alter the lumbar biomechanics during landing tasks, Applied Ergonomics, 65 (2017) 123-129.
- S.N. Zhang, B.T. Bates and J.S. Dufek, Contributions of lower extremity joints to energy dissipation during landings, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 32 (2000) 812-819.
- J.G. Seegmiller and ST. McCaw, Ground reaction forces among gymnasts and recreational athletes in drop landings, Journal of Athletic Training, 38 (2003) 311-314.
- A.R. Mason-Mackay, C. Whatman and D. Reid, The effect of reduced ankle dorsiflexion on lower extremity mechanics during landing: A systematic review, Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport 20 (2017) 451-458.
- CR James, B.W. Scheuermann and M.P. Smith, Effects of two neuromuscular fatigue protocols on landing performance, Journal of Electromyography and Kinesiology, 20 (2010) 667-675.
- A.D. Nordin and J.S. Dufek, Lower extremity variability changes with drop-landing height manipulations, Research in Sports Medicine, 25 (2017) 144-155.
- C. Bishop, A. Turner and P. Read, Effects of inter-limb asymmetries on physical and sports performance: a systematic review, Journal of Sports Sciences, 36 (2018) 1135-1144.
- E. Pappas and F.P. Carpes, Lower extremity kinematic asymmetry in male and female athletes performing jump-landing tasks, Journal of Science and Medicine in Sport, 15 (2012) 87-92.
- L. Seifert, C. Button and K. Davids, Key properties of expert movement systems in sport, Sports Medicine, 43 (2013) 167-178.
- H.J.S. Shih, D.N. Jarvis, P Mikkelsen, and K. Kulig, Interlimb force coordination in rate-controlled dance specific bipedal jumps: comparison between experts and novices, Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 29 (2018) 1-23.
- J.R. Harry, J.F. Silvernail, J.A. Mercer and J.S. Dufek, Bilateral comparison of vertical jump landings and step-off landings from equal heights, The Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 32 (2018) 1937-1947.
- M. Afifi and R.N. Hinrichs, A mechanics comparison between landing from a countermovement jump and landing from stepping off a box, Journal of Applied Biomechanics, 28 (2012) 1-9.